Home AboutArchivesBest Of Subscribe

I’ll Tell You a Story…

TV Comedy

Today, we’re going to answer a huge burning question about The Young Ones. No, nothing to do with flash frames, or hidden fifth housemates. This is the really important stuff.

Exactly what is the farty neighbour watching on her television in “Cash”, just before she switches over to Andy De La Tour doing a public information film?

The television with a mystery cartoon on
The television with the PIF on


Squinting at it, it seems impossible to tell. Some kind of drawing of a car? Unless it’s some well-known cartoon, or mentioned in the paperwork for rights reasons, or specified in the script, how could we ever figure it out?

Spoiler: it’s not a well-known cartoon, or mentioned on the paperwork for rights reasons, or specified in the script. We have only our wits to go on here.

Well… wits, and a certain video of Young Ones raw studio footage, sitting patiently on YouTube. I wrote recently about the section of this video containing material for the episode “Nasty”, but the second half of the video is entirely dedicated to “Cash”. And crucially, it includes the entire recording session for this scene.

Here are the same two images as above, this time taken from that raw footage:

The television with a mystery cartoon on - from raw studio footage with timecode
The television with the PIF on - from raw studio footage with timecode


Take a look at the burnt-in timecode at the bottom. This actually represents the time of day. So, we now know the exact time the scene was shot: 4:28pm. Does this help?

Possibly. Because if we skip back three minutes, and watch them setting up to record the scene:

TV with mirror globe on
TV with... a person on?


Hang on, is that a BBC1 mirror globe ident I see? Why is that there?

The answer is simple. If the ident is there, that means that all this footage isn’t being played in from VTR to the television prop, like you might expect. Instead, it means that BBC1 network output is being routed to the television set: literally, exactly what was on BBC1 at the time the scene was being recorded. This actually does make sense considering when the show was made; in 1984, VTRs were a precious resource. You wouldn’t want to tie one up unless you had to. When watching the raw studio footage, it’s obvious that even Andy De La Tour is being shot live in another part of the studio, and simply routed to the TV prop; they didn’t pre-record any of that, either.

So, we now know that whatever was playing on that television is what was on BBC1 at 4:25pm. So the final part of this puzzle is figuring out the date. When was this episode shot? Let’s consult the paperwork…

Paperwork for Cash

“Cash” was shot on the 30th and 31st of January 1984, in Studio 3 at Television Centre. The 30th would have been the pre-record day, where they shot all the complicated effects-heavy sequences, and the 31st would be the audience record session. The raw footage video is clearly from the pre-record day; there is no audience present.

Which means the programme we are searching for was on BBC1 at 4:25pm, on the 30th January 1984. We don’t even need to resort to a paper Radio Times to nail this down; we can go straight to BBC Genome. And we now have our answer.

The programme on farty woman’s telly was Jackanory. Specifically, Episode 1 of an adaptation of The Phantom Tollbooth, Norton Juster’s 1961 book about a kid and his, erm, magic tollbooth. It was read by Christopher Guard, and at the precise moment it showed up on The Young Ones the episode was getting its only repeat ever; it was originally shown on the 14th March 1983.

And if you want final proof of all this, I’ve managed to get hold of a copy of this exact episode of Jackanory. So let’s go back to the raw studio footage one final time, and compare what’s on the TV screen straight after the globe ident with the very beginning of The Phantom Tollbooth:

TV with... a person on?
TV with... a person on? Full quality


So if you want to see exactly what was on farty woman’s television in the final, broadcast scene in “Cash”:

The television with a mystery cartoon on
TV with... a person on? Full quality


Which just leaves us with the following to ponder: how technical limitations in 1984 meant that the easiest way of capturing this scene was simply including whatever was randomly on BBC1 at the time of recording. Today, with it being far easier to play back whatever material you like, it’s hard to imagine that ever happening. Something specific would be chosen. If only for rights concerns as much as anything.

But in 1984, with The Young Ones? Completely at random, Farty Woman just doesn’t like Jackanory.

I think this article is the best thing published on the entire internet.

Read more about...

,

12 comments

Derek Smalls on 15 January 2021 @ 12pm

This is the reason why the internet was invented. Poirot-esque level of deductive reasoning and attention to detail. Bravo sir. Bravo.


4DC5 on 15 January 2021 @ 12pm

This is brilliant.


Richard Drew on 15 January 2021 @ 1pm

Working in telly as I have since 1988, I’ve never known this. Aside from the cost of a VCR, it may well have been the simplest way to do it and nobody thought anything of it. Certainly now the rights of shows ( you have to get permissions long in advance ) you would not be allowed to get away with. I work in the Art Dept and picture clearance, graphic clearances are the bane of my life. – great article. Amazing work.


Kevin West on 15 January 2021 @ 1pm

What a relief, after all the shenanigans with the music paperwork, that there’s other ways of figuring this out and getting to the answer!


Lee Realgone on 15 January 2021 @ 2pm

Brilliant work, sir! Now find us the studio footage of ‘Oh Crikey!’ so we don’t have to watch it through a murky TV set.


SteveP on 15 January 2021 @ 2pm

Great detective work! More please! 👍😁


Martin Lowrie on 15 January 2021 @ 4pm

Excellent work there Mr Homes! This article helped me pass a short while and at the time of typing its thick with snow outside! So reading the article kept me inside and out of the freezing temperatures outside well done again for your diligent detective work!


Adam Tandy on 15 January 2021 @ 5pm

@Richard Drew In 1988 the chances of the copyright not being owned entirely by the BBC would be very small. I wonder if Christopher Guard is listed on the PasC. If he appeared in the final programme he’d be due repeats…


Joe Dredd on 15 January 2021 @ 9pm

Lovely textural detail. It reminds me of when I discovered Zaphod Beeblebrox in Only Fools & Horses!


Howard on 16 January 2021 @ 12am

This is honestly the best thing I’ve this year so far. More please.


Olllie on 16 January 2021 @ 11am

OMG this is amazing!!


John Hoare on 20 January 2021 @ 6am

Thanks everyone. The reaction to this piece has been far more than I ever thought it would be!

Adam: I’ve just checked, and Christopher Guard is not on the PasC. By pure luck, the only actual footage from the Jackanory episode is that car drawing, and the audio isn’t present either. I wonder if they would have done the necessary if he *had* appeared, though…


Comments on this post are now closed.